What Advice Do You Have for Integrating New Construction into Established Neighborhoods?

What Advice Do You Have for Integrating New Construction into Established Neighborhoods?

When it comes to blending new construction into existing neighborhoods, architects have a unique perspective on the challenge. From communicating early with planning officials to balancing integration with architectural variety, we've gathered four pieces of advice from seasoned architects and principals. These insights aim to ensure new developments complement their well-established surroundings.

• Communicate Early with Planning Officials
• Study Surrounding Architecture Thoroughly
• Create Cohesion with Details and Materials
• Balance Integration with Architectural Variety

Communicate Early with Planning Officials

There's so much to do here, but my one piece of advice is to have your architect communicate early and often with the building department. An open dialogue will get the planning officials familiar with your project on a deeper level, so they understand why you're doing certain things, and will reduce any knee-jerk rejection reactions that might occur if they see the design for the first time when it is submitted for permits.

Study Surrounding Architecture Thoroughly

As an architect with over 30 years of experience designing homes in Chicago, my advice is to study the surrounding architecture thoroughly. Note details like materials, scale, setbacks, and rhythm of the street facade. Match or complement these elements in your new design. For example, if homes have a common brick or stone, incorporate that into your home. If they share a consistent shape or roofline, reflect that in your design.

Also, walk the neighborhood and observe how people use their space. Try to complement and improve on that. For instance, if many neighbors enjoy gardening, design space for a garden. If people value privacy, make sure your windows don't look directly into theirs.

Finally, be a considerate neighbor throughout the construction process. Control noise, parking, and debris. Communicate with neighbors about the schedule and address any concerns. Your goal should be enhancing the neighborhood, not disrupting it. If you design and build with care and respect for what exists, your new home will integrate seamlessly.

Create Cohesion with Details and Materials

As a contractor with over 15 years of experience building ADUs and working within established neighborhoods, I would advise paying close attention to the surrounding architecture and seamlessly integrating new construction. For a recent ADU project, we matched the roof pitch, siding, windows, and color scheme to the main house and neighboring properties. We also kept the ADU compact by building up an extra level rather than expanding out, which maintained the yard space.

High-quality, low-maintenance materials are key. We often use AZEK decking and TimberTech railing, which provide the appearance of real wood without the maintenance. These composites hold up well to weather and visually integrate new construction.

Details like lighting, fencing, and landscaping tie everything together. For one project, we installed cedar fencing, pathway lighting, and native plants to create cohesion between the new ADU and the existing property. With careful integration, new construction strengthens neighborhood character rather than detracts from it.

Balance Integration with Architectural Variety

So much of the answer to this question hangs on the definition of 'seamlessly' and the context of the neighborhood. Sure, fitting in with the context of the neighborhood is most palatable to the general population, but if our neighborhoods lack variety, would we find them interesting? Taking cues from existing buildings and their use of materials, scale, and form are great places to start. But then again, would we love buildings like the Guggenheim in New York or the Louvre Pyramid if they followed rules of scale and form as many other infill projects do? Rules of architecture are not one-size-fits-all. Architecture, just like any other art, will be seamlessly loved and hated all at the same time.